Thomas Aquinas on the Damnation of Unbaptized Infants

aprilis 24, 2007

Just this past week the Vatican published a document expressing hope for the salvation of unbaptized infants. (Read about it here).  Now, I don’t have a dog in this race, but as a curious onlooker, I wonder whether this portends a shift in the catholic understanding of original sin, baptism and grace.

Read the rest of this entry »


Boethius Consolation Book IV, Chapters 1 and 2.

aprilis 23, 2007

Book IV of the Consolation begins the discussion of God’s providence and the problem of evil. Boethius has asked why, if God is sovereign, omniscient, omnipotent and good, do evils happen to the virtuous and the vicious escape unpunished (313-315)? Philosophy’s counterargument will attempt to show that this is not actually the case, but rather the virtuous are always rewarded and the vicious always punished, even within this life—there is no discussion of final judgment, heaven or hell in the first two chapters.

Read the rest of this entry »

Can philosophy provide an insight into reality that surpasses that which science offers?

aprilis 21, 2007

[The following was my response to an exam at my graduate program. The idea of this exam is that it is unprepared and ex tempore. One has 4 hours to write a response to one of three very broad question on the nature of philosophy. The title of this post indicates the question that I chose to answer and the body of the post indicates my response to it. I post it on the off chance that somebody is morbidly curious as to my own philosophical opinions.]

Read the rest of this entry »

Luther on Thomas on Transubstantiation

aprilis 20, 2007

Here’s an interesting little gem from that tenacious teutonic rabblerouser I came across in an article on the history of the doctrine of transubstantiation. I post it for your edification, amusement and amazement.

Read the rest of this entry »

Grossteste Resource

aprilis 17, 2007

There is now an electronic edition of the works of Grossteste available online.

Boethius, Book III, Prose XII

aprilis 16, 2007

Having proven that all things seek the good and that God is the good, the conversation turns in book III, prose XII to the theme of God’s governance over the world, preparing us for the discussion of providence and the existence of evil in later books.

Philosophy argues for three attributes of God’s governance. First, God’s governance is good, insofar as God has been shown to be the good himself. Second, God’s governance is voluntary. According to Philosophy, all things “are ruled voluntarily” by God’s governance insofar as they seek their own good, which is ultimately God himself (301). Therefore, nothing “while remaining true to its own nature would try to go against God” (303). Third, God’s governance is irresistible.

Read the rest of this entry »

Barth, Plantinga, and the possibility of proofs of God’s existence

aprilis 11, 2007

This is slightly off topic, but might be of interest to some of you. My friend David posted a  sentence from Barth’s Romans commentary which, by the title of the post, David felt undermined the claims of the intelligent design movement. There have been several comments on the post exploring the themes of natural theology, the role of the Christian philosopher and the provability of the existence of God, including one by yours truly.

If you would like to contribute some thoughts,  please leave them at David’s blog.